Using Your Equity

Secured Versus Unsecured Loans for Higher Education

College graduates that considered using secured vs unsecured loans to finance their higher education

Almost 20 million Americans pursue higher education every year. Of those 20 million, a very high percentage borrow funds to pay for their educational expenses. As a result, more students are graduating with educational debt than ever before.

In most cases, students have the option to choose between federal loans and private loans. For students pursuing costly degrees, it is not uncommon for them to take out both federal and private loans.

Federal loans are loans distributed by the federal government and are widely available to students pursuing higher education. Congress sets the interest rates for federal student loans each year and they are often relatively low compared to private loans.

Private loans are loans offered by private banks and lending institutions. Typically, your interest rate and borrowing ability for private loans are limited by your credit history. Although, with a co-signer, you can often increase your borrowing capacity.

Private loans are also offered in different ways. Primarily, private loans used to pay for higher education come in the form of secured or unsecured loans.

Let’s explore the difference between secured and unsecured loans below.

Loans for Higher Education: Secured Versus Unsecured

Banks offer two categories of loans—secured and unsecured.

Secured loans are loans that require the borrower to provide an asset or collateral in exchange for the loan money. If the borrower fails to pay their loan, the bank can keep or sell the provided asset or collateral to satisfy the debt.

Examples of secured loans include mortgages, home equity loans, home equity lines of credit and car loans.

Secured Loans for Higher Education

Believe it or not, home equity loans can be a lending tool for students pursuing higher education. While student loans carry relatively low interest rates, you may be able to secure an equally low (or lower) rate by using a home equity loan, so long as you meet certain lending criteria. Discover Home Loans, in particular, has rates from 3.99% - 11.99% APR*. In addition, Discover Home Loans doesn’t charge application, origination, or appraisal fees, and no cash is required at closing.

* Fixed rates starting at 3.99% APR for first liens and 4.15% APR for second liens.

The APR will be between 3.99% and 8.99% for first liens and 4.15% and 11.99% for second liens based on loan amount and a review of credit-worthiness, including income and property information, at the time of application. The lowest APRs are available to borrowers requesting at least $80,000 for second liens or $150,001 for first liens, with the best credit and other factors. Loan amounts available from $35,000 to $200,000.

Secured loans, can be risky because failure to pay your loan could result in the loss of the asset or collateral you provided in exchange for the funds. For example, if you were to obtain a home equity loan to pay for your educational expenses, your home would serve as collateral for the loan, which allows you to get competitive rates. Failure to pay your loan could put your home at risk. For this reason, you must consider whether or not you can meet your loan obligation terms before borrowing.

Take advantage of the benefits of a secured loan by planning ahead and beginning the application process early.

Unsecured Loans for Higher Education

The second category of loans offered by private banks and institutions is the unsecured loan. Unsecured loans do not require the borrower to provide any assets or collateral in exchange for the loan. Obtaining an unsecured loan rests solely on your creditworthiness. Most educational loans are unsecured loans. Small personal loans are also usually unsecured.

If you obtain an unsecured loan from the government, you will likely be assigned an interest rate set by Congress during that time. However, if you get an unsecured loan from a private bank, your interest rate will depend on your credit score and borrower’s profile.

Unsecured loans are good options for students who lack the assets or collateral necessary to obtain a secured loan. Most students can easily obtain unsecured student loans, and when required, can leverage the assistance of a co-signer to get the funds they need to pay for school.

However, if you enlist the support of a co-signer, always be sure they understand what they are signing up for. Having a co-signer means that if you fail to pay your loan, your co-signer will be required to step up and be responsible for the payments. This is a significant commitment, so make sure everyone involved understands what they’re agreeing to in this type of arrangement.

Which Loan is Better: Secured Versus Unsecured?

Both secured and unsecured loans are seen as debt on your credit profile. In fact, secured and unsecured loans impact your credit score in similar ways. If you make late payments or default on either a secured or unsecured loan, both are reported to the credit bureaus.

While lenders can repossess the collateral you provide for secured loans, if your guarantee doesn’t cover the borrowed amount, lenders can pursue any remaining debt in court. The same goes for unsecured loans.

So, which wins: Secured Versus Unsecured Loans?

Realistically, secured and unsecured loans are not necessarily good or bad. They are different. The most important thing for you to consider is how the features and benefits of each category of loans will affect you.

If you are in a position to afford payments on a secured loan like a home equity loan, the benefits of low rates and no fees can be advantageous.

On the other hand, if you need a loan, but don’t have collateral to offer in exchange for the loan, consider an unsecured loan. Just be sure to analyze your repayment schedule carefully and determine if your projected income will cover your expenses upon graduating.

The Bottom Line

The world of educational lending is rich with options for students of every kind. The key to navigating the process is to educate yourself thoroughly on those options.

Find your low,
fixed rate

Use our Rate Calculator to find the  rate and monthly payment that  fits your budget.


Start your application online

or give us a call.

  • Weekdays 8am–Midnight ET
  • Weekends 10am–6pm ET

Start your application online or give us a call.

  • Weekdays 8am–Midnight ET
  • Weekends 10am–6pm ET