Dad and daughter sit together at a desk.

What’s the Difference Between Nonprofit Credit Counselors and Debt Settlement Companies?

Last Updated: March 11, 2022
7 min read

Reputable nonprofit credit counseling agencies may offer credit counselors who are trained and certified in consumer credit, debt management and other money matters, whereas debt settlement companies typically are in business mainly to make a profit, rather than to help consumers better manage their financial lives.

The difference between nonprofit credit counselors and debt settlement companies is an important one to understand if you’re seeking help with managing debt. Read on to learn what you need to know before reaching out for assistance.

How can a nonprofit credit counselor help you?

According to the Federal Trade Commission, one of the best places to get help dealing with debt is a nonprofit credit counseling agency. Here are some of the benefits to choosing a nonprofit credit counselor for help handling debt:

You can usually get free, no-strings-attached help when contacting a nonprofit credit counseling agency. Many nonprofit credit counseling agencies offer their counseling services free of charge. You may be charged fees as it relates to debt management programs (covered in more detail below).

Counselors are qualified. Nonprofit credit counselors typically go through intensive training and must pass stringent tests to get certified to counsel consumers on money matters such as credit card debt, mortgages, student loans and bankruptcy.

Credit counseling can address the root cause. A credit counselor will work with you and help you figure out why you got into debt and how to develop healthy financial habits. 

Debt management fees are low. Many credit counseling agencies offer debt management plans, or DMPs, which can be a good solution for some Cardmembers. Remember to always review all your options and understand exactly what is being offered when selecting a credit counselor before agreeing to their terms.

How do nonprofit credit counselors work?

Most nonprofit credit counseling agencies offer counseling online, by phone or in person.

The counselor will review your overall financial picture, including income, bills, debt and other obligations such as child support. Taking this information into account, the counselor will help you decide on a plan to deal with your debt. The counselor also can help you create a realistic household budget that includes debt repayment.

If you qualify for a Debt Management Plan (DMP), the value is in your hard-earned money going toward paying down your debt in a responsible manner. Using a DMP, your payment is going toward your debt and continuously chipping away at the balance, rather than toward a percentage cut a consolidator may take from you.

A DMP does not come without some credit history impacts, however, but they are preferable to a situation in which you don’t repay your debt and experience a charge-off. When you enroll in a DMP, your accounts are revoked, which means they are permanently closed. This could be viewed as a negative event by lenders, because the creditor closed them upon agreement to using a DMP. On the other hand, the benefit to a DMP is that you’re less likely to experience a charge-off of your accounts since you are making on-time, acceptable payments to your creditors. The same cannot be said for debt settlement companies, in which the consolidator may allow the account to charge-off before reaching out to creditors on your behalf.

However, you need to do some legwork to make sure a credit counseling organization is legitimate. It’s important to ask questions about credit counseling services to choose a reputable agency. 

What you should know about debt settlement companies

A debt settlement company is often a for-profit business that charges consumers for services related to debt resolution. These companies go by many names — including debt settlement company, debt relief company, debt consolidation company or debt negotiation service, among others — and will vary in terms of what they will claim to be able to achieve.

These companies may have you open up an escrow account with them, into which you make payments each month. Ultimately, you are just paying into that escrow account and not making payments to your credit cards or other loans. Once you’ve paid a certain amount into the account — that amount is determined by the Debt Settlement Company — one of their representatives will reach out to your creditors to make settlement offers. There is no guarantee those offers will be accepted by your creditors, so this can be a risky option that could leave you in a difficult financial situation. If a certain amount of time goes by, eventually the accounts will be charged off by the creditors and lenders, which is considered a very negative event in your credit history.

Keep in mind that the consolidation offered by a debt settlement company is different from consolidating your debt through a financial product such as a personal loan, credit card balance transfer, or home equity loan from your bank or credit union, which can be a good option for some consumers. However, you would need to have a strong enough credit score and credit history to be approved for this type of option.

Common slogans used by debt settlement companies may include language like: “Slash your debt by 60 percent!” or “Drowning in debt? We can help you become debt free,” and “Settle your debt for pennies on the dollar!”

While these ads may sound tempting, there are some big risks you should consider before signing on the dotted line:

Can you really trust a debt settlement company? A debt settlement company typically is selling a particular service, rather than trying to find the solution that’s right for your situation.

The debt settlement company takes over power of attorney of your account. When you sign on the dotted line, you’re usually transferring the power of attorney to the debt settlement company, which means they can make the decisions on your account going forward.

Some risks include debt settlement companies charging steep fees. You can also ruin your credit by relying on services like these. Debt settlement typically takes many months and can result in late payments, charge-offs and other negatives that can adversely affect your credit report.

Results are never guaranteed. Some companies make big promises, but remember that they can’t eliminate your debt. Also, a debt settlement company has no way of knowing the results in advance.

Debt settlement companies may be looking to strike a deal with creditors. However, customers don’t get any financial education in the process. This means that debt settlement customers may head back into financial problems again.

Weighing your debt settlement options

Still not sure where to turn? Perhaps an example will be useful: Say a consumer, Sally Smith, owes $10,000 across five credit cards. She goes to a debt settlement company that charges a fee of 25 percent of the total amount of debt settled. If the debt settlement company is able to get her creditors to settle for 50 percent of what Sally owes, she could end up having to come up with $5,000 quickly to pay her creditors, on top of paying $1,250 to the debt settlement company.

There’s also risk involved in the way the process works. The debt settlement company tells consumer Sally to stop paying her credit card bills, so as each month goes by, the accounts become further delinquent and the creditors are (they hope) more willing to settle. In the meantime, her debt may balloon, as late fees and interest charges continue to accrue on the balance and her credit gets damaged.

In contrast, if Sally had signed up for a DMP through a credit counseling agency, she might have paid a total of $300 or $400 in administration fees to the credit counseling agency. The agency may have been able to negotiate lower interest rates and fee waivers with her creditors, resulting in one manageable monthly payment.

Additionally, some creditors, including Discover, may be able to offer payment programs that reduce interest and therefore create an opportunity for the customer to better manage their payments.  For that reason, you may also want to reach out to your creditor to discuss your options for repayment if you are struggling.

The next time you see a flashy ad from a debt settlement company, consider this: Some of that advertising is funded by the fees paid by the customers.

Was this article helpful?

Thank you for your feedback!